Why insurance keeps throwing people at the back office (and why that's stopped working)

 |  22 November 2026

Blog_Back Office

I spent ten years in IT teams inside insurance companies before we started Grappler. One thing I noticed everywhere I worked was that the technology investment went into the front end, things like customer experience, portals and pricing. The back office got spreadsheets, workarounds and, when things got really hard, more people.


Do nothing, outsource, or throw more people at it. That was the answer back then.

The frustrating part was that everyone knew these problems existed. The people doing the work certainly did! But when it came to deciding where to invest, the back office just wasn't a priority.

I can understand why. Margins were healthier, and hiring probably felt safer than another technology project that might not deliver. I've seen enough software implementations that promised the earth but left teams relying on workarounds.

But with margins under pressure and businesses managing more transactions, products and markets, throwing more people at the problem is becoming an increasingly expensive way to stand still.

The cost of doing nothing

Working with insurance finance teams through Grappler, I've seen the results of what happens when businesses keep adding people instead of addressing the problems underneath.

It's not just the cost of the extra headcount. It's the issues get carried from one month to the next because no one has time to investigate them. It's the spreadsheet that only one person understands. It's all the manual checks and workarounds that have become so embedded in daily operations that no one questions them anymore.

As businesses grow, these problems grow with them. Teams are so busy 'doing' they don't have the headspace to think about improving how it's done.

Things often come to a head at year-end, when months of unresolved issues all need sorting all at once. Throwing more people at the problem might get you through another close, but it won't stop the exact same thing happening next time.

Automating the work isn't the same as fixing the problem

One of the things we've learned at Grappler is that automation has a way of exposing problems that have been hiding in the data for years.

Missing policy information, inconsistent premium amounts, incorrect commission calculations. Problems that people have been manually working around, sometimes without realising how often they're occurring.

When you stop spending all your time processing transactions, you can start investigating why things are going wrong.

I think it's is worth remembering with all the excitement around AI agents that matching transactions is one thing, but understanding why they don't match, identifying what's missing and addressing the underlying cause is another thing entirely.

Automating a task won't automatically improve how your financial operations work. And if your underlying data is wrong, automating the process won't magically make your numbers right.

I believe the real opportunity for the back office is to connect financial information across the business, account for transactions as they happen and give finance teams the visibility to identify and resolve problems before they become month-end headaches.

The question to ask

If your answer to growth is still "we'll hire another person to handle the workload", it's worth asking whether that solution will still work when your business is twice the size.

Or when you enter another market, acquire another business or introduce more complex products.

We've spent decades investing in how insurance businesses win and service customers, while the financial operations behind them have been expected to somehow keep up.

After twenty years in the industry, I think we've spent long enough accepting that this is just how the back office works.

It isn't. And our customers are proving it.

Get the latest news and insights